stanford law school protest video

You've successfully subscribed to this newsletter! Most of dean Martinez class joined the protest and those who didnt join got the stink eye from the protesters. Megyn Kelly is joined by Tim Rosenberger, President of the Federalist Society at Stanford University, to discuss how Stanford students and colleagues disresp. Rosenberger said Martinez had met with him and appeared to recognize this was bigger than a mere policy about campus speech. [6] Like most other video games, the difficulty of the game is adjusted according to each players progress, by measuring their performance through adaptive algorithms but for EndeavorRx the difficulty adjustment is specifically created in a manner to provide a player with a personalized treatment experience. 00:01 00:51 Stanford Law School shouldn't have caved and catered to a "woke mob" that derailed a lecture given by a Trump-appointed federal judge and then issue an apology for the ambush, a. Published under: Tim Rosenberger is president of the Stanford chapter of the Federalist Society, which invited Judge Kyle Duncan to speak earlier this month. The contents of this website are copyright 1990-2023 New This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, ", "I think for the average person who just has normal views, it's a very confusing place because you're sort of invited to join the mob or whatever that was that shouted down Judge Duncan, or you're told you're some kind of bigot, and you might not really agree with Judge Duncan's positions, but you might also think very reasonably that if you disagree with some of these positions, and you're planning on entering the legal profession, you send them an email or talk to them privately," he said. Tirien Steinbach will be leaving her role as associate dean for diversity, equity and inclusion "to pursue another opportunity," Dean Jenny Martinez said . Shapiro called for consequences for those who violated Stanford's free speech policies. "I'm really sort of heartened that people are interested in this and find it shocking, because for about a day there, I just wondered if I was a crazy person. Adding a video game component to DTx contributes to both the effectiveness and accessibility components of DTx, and it also adds an entertaining reward-based component to DTx which makes it more attractive, especially to kids. Video game developers will have to keep the distinction between general wellness video games and game-based DTx in mind when bringing new video games with a health component to the market. De Novo Classification Request for EndeavorRx. Stanford Law DEI dean who went viral for scolding Trump-appointed judge Hundreds of students continued to demand his firing. She hoped to join the girls cross country and track teams at her school, butbecause she is transgender, she was not allowed to under a West Virginia law, which provides that school athletes must play for the team that corresponds with their biological sex. She sued to challenge this law. Get the inside scoop on todays biggest stories in business, from Wall Street to Silicon Valley delivered daily. One source told me the event ended about 40 minutes before the scheduled end time., Duncan told the Beaconthe student protesters behaved like dog shit, and that if enough of these kids get into the legal profession, the rule of law will descend into barbarism., After the aborted event, Duncan told Lat he heard that Steinbach was claiming two things: The first was that he did not have any prepared remarks for his speech (they actually were on his iPad) and was just looking to stir up trouble. The second was the fact that marshals had to escort him out of the building was proof he is a rabble rouser., You dont invite someone to your campus to scream and hurl invective at them, Duncan said. A representative of one of the nations leading law schools seemed to be telling a prominent member of the Federalist Society a sitting federal judge! The resignation comes after student journalists uncovered . In 2020, EndeavorRx made headlines as the first-ever prescription video game to be cleared by the FDA. She also alleged that Duncan hadnt prepared a speecha claim contradicted by video of the judge holding pages of pre-written remarksand that he was a serial provocateur, belittling law students everywhere he's spoken in order to rile them up for the cameras. The protest followed a flurry of open letters from student activists, who spent much of the weekend berating Martinez after she and Stanford University president Marc Tessier-Lavigne issued a formal apology to Duncan condemning the students who disrupted his talk and the administrators who stood by silently and watched them do so. They also claimed he is opposed to same-sex marriage and black Americans right to vote, according to The Washington Free Beacon. Stanfords policies on free speech allow for noisy protests outside an event and for non-disruptive protests (such as holding signs) inside an event. Another student who chose not to join the protest yesterday noted the irony. "Making sure that . {snip}. REPORTER WARNS STANFORD STUDENTS' FREE SPEECH DOUBLE STANDARD COULD BECOME MAINSTREAM AMONG LAWYERS, JUDGES. The FDA classified EndeavorRx as a game-based DTx through their de novo, premarket review pathway for low- to moderate-risk devices of a new type, creating a new regulatory classification for game-based DTx. Hundreds of students dressed in black and donning face masks emblazoned with the words "counter-speech is free speech" lined the halls of Stanford Law on Monday to . The fliers parroted the argument, made by student activists, that the hecklers veto is a form of free speech. Stanford Law hecklers demanding 'free speech' don't know what they're The implication of the new regulatory classification is that devices of the same type with the same intended use can obtain FDA clearance through the Section 510(k) process only, instead of the de novo classification path, by demonstrating that the device is substantially equivalent to EndeavorRx. Mayhem at Stanford Law School as Students Protest Judge, with Law Tessier-Lavigne has been the school's president since 2016. Stanford Law School Ousts Diversity Dean Who Egged on Protest of Federal Judge, < Harris Blasts Floridas History Standards Claim Slavery Included Benefit to Black Americans, The Rise and Fall of the Chief Diversity Officer >, The Supreme Court Ruling on Affirmative Action Is a Catastrophe, Verified Hate: Twitter Still Cant Handle AmRen, Richard Lynn: a Wonderful Man and a Great Scientist. By clicking Sign up, you agree to receive marketing emails from Insider , Further, being a visual method of treatment instead of an informational-based treatment method, game-based DTx is more accessible to younger individuals and individuals who have limited literacy skills. if you tried to engineer a controversy in a lab with the goal of outraging a Court dominated by Federalist Society stalwarts, you would come up with something like this confrontation, The five most conservative members of the Supreme Court are all regular speakers at Federalist Society events, including at a banquet the Federalist Society hosts every year as part of its annual lawyers convention. New video shows Stanford protesters heckling Trump judge as DEI dean Stanford University Campus in 2021. Eunhye Choi, Eun-Ha Yoon & Min-Hyeon Park, Game-based digital therapeutics for children and adolescents: Their therapeutic effects on mental health problems, the sustainability of the therapeutic effects and the transfer of cognitive functions. The law schools Immigration & Human Rights Law Association issued a similar declaration on Sunday, writing to its mailing list that Stanfords apology to Duncan "has only made this situation worse." The cancel culture incident has gained so much ridicule and outrage against Stanford that Stanford President Marc Tessier-Lavigne and Stanford Law Dean Jenny Martinez issued an apology Saturday to Judge Duncan and a pledge to ensure such boisterous disruptions never happen again. Martinez said at the start of her class that she had received a number of emails complaining about her apology to Duncan but told students they would not be litigating that dispute during Mondays class. L ess than a week after Judge Kyle Duncan's controversial appearance at Stanford Law School, another public servant, Congressman Ted Lieu, spoke at Stanford. [3] Office of the Commissioner, FDA Permits Marketing of First Game-Based Digital Therapeutic to Improve Attention Function in Children with ADHD, FDA (2020), https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-permits-marketing-first-game-based-digital-therapeutic-improve-attention-function-children-adhd. [12] Game-based DTx has the potential to change the way we think about video games and can bring about disruption in both the video game and healthcare industry. Whelan said that if Stanford is serious about taking steps to ensure that something like this does not happen again, the first thing it can do is to fire Dean Steinbach. WFB Reporter Explains Why Woke Stanford Law Students Who Tried to The Stanford Law School diversity dean will step down after her much-criticized scolding of a conservative federal judge who was shouted down by student protesters at a campus appearance. The prescription is fulfilled by Phil Pharmacy, which specializes in digital treatment prescriptions and provides the patient with an activation code to activate the EndeavorRx app. "It didnt feel like the inclusive, belonging atmosphere that the DEI office claims to be creating. The Beacon reported that in the week prior to the event, Stanford students had begun a public shaming peer pressure campaign against the Federalist Society members who had invited Duncan in an effort to get the talk canceled. Stanford later commissioned its own report by an outside law firm after students revealed the fraud in papers affiliated with Tessier Lavigne. Circuit Court of Appeals, was supposed to deliver a lecture at the law school on Thursday, but he was disrupted by a group of protesters composed primarily of students but also included Tirien Steinbach, the school's dean of diversity, equity, and inclusion. See the full episode here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Npri0P6UY-U Did you knowLOOPcast is on your favorite podcast platform. And, the video game component also provides individuals with a stronger sense of agency and achievement, keeping them motivated to engage with the therapy.[12]. [3], Video games, started primarily as entertainment products, however, their capability to materially affect players bodies, brains and behavior has become more recognized in the health and video game industry. Currently, EndeavorRxs website lists the cash price for the treatment as USD99.00, and some insurance companies, Highmark BCBS Insurance is specifically listed, will cover the costs. I did. This will provide game-based DTx developers with an incentive to obtain FDA prescription approval, for their games to be covered by insurance companies. [8] If this growth trend continues in the game-based DTx market, we might see a new leading industry within both the healthcare and video game industries in the next couple of years. Stanford law dean faces student revolt after apologizing to Trump Reporter Aaron Sibarium rips Stanford law students for demanding anonymity after protest: 'Double standard'. A video showing two women being paraded naked by a mob in the north-eastern state of Manipur, hit by violent ethnic clashes, has sparked outrage in India. March 23, 2023. Aaron Sibarium has been covering the Stanford Law School deplatforming of Judge Kyle Duncan closely and today he has another scoop about something that happened at the school yesterday. The embattled dean arrived to the classroom where she teaches constitutional law to find a whiteboard covered inch to inch in fliers attacking Duncan and defending those who disrupted him, according to photos of the room and multiple eyewitness accounts. MORE: Stanford Law students walk out on speaker discussing legality of DACA repeal, But then Steinbach said she understood that some people feel like the harm is so great that we might need to reconsider those [free speech] policies., I hope that you have something to share with us that we can learn from, she told the judge. Circuit Judge Stuart Kyle Duncan in her email, writing that both she and Steinbach hope the law school "can move forward" from the . Jewish Students Reported a Professor for Anti-Semitism. In Part II I will discuss the FDA's clearance of EndeavorRx. The school's investigation found evidence of manipulation and "serious flaws in the presentation of research data," though it also found that the Stanford president himself "did not have actual knowledge" of the manipulation. (2020), https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-permits-marketing-first-game-based-digital-therapeutic-improve-attention-function-children-adhd. [1] Amit Dang, Dimple Arora & Pawan Rane, Role of digital therapeutics and the changing future of healthcare, 9 Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care 2207 (2020). The student protesters, who formed a human corridor from Martinezs classroom to the buildings exit, comprised nearly a third of the law school, the students told the Washington Free Beacon. In a prepared statement, Steinbach said she was pained to inform Duncan that he was welcome here at Stanford to give his talk. Tristin Brynn Hooker & Martha Sue Karnes, More than serious: Medicine, games, and care, A novel digital intervention for actively reducing severity of paediatric ADHD (STARS-ADHD): a randomised controlled trial, General Wellness: Policy for Low Risk Devices. ", WATCH: Joe Biden's Senior Moment of the Week (Vol. April 3, 2023. And Stanford Law Schools chapter of the American Constitution Society expressed outrage that Martinez and Tessier-Lavigne had framed Duncan "as a victim, when in fact he himself had made civil dialogue impossible. This is how they think they need to behave.". cultural affinity groups cant decide if theyre angry or not about meeting spaces, Reactions to Oppenheimer reveal the failure of our education system. [8] As a game-based DTx, EndeavorRx provides a non-drug option to improve ADHD symptoms in children in a manner which is fun and engaging. Canadian university changes BIPOC to IBPOC because indigenous oppression is unique, Black university lecturer wont take daughter to Barbie due to its unintentional whiteness, Duke U. In 2022 two new bills were introduced in the Senate, the Access to Prescription Digital Therapeutics Act and the Medicaid and CHIP Access to Prescription Digital Therapeutics Act. [2], DTx aims to increase the effectiveness and accessibility of healthcare by providing a non-drug personalized treatment experience. Duncan joined GianCarlo Canaparo, a senior legal fellow at The Heritage Foundation, on the "SCOTUS 101" podcast to discuss a protest at Stanford Law School, which prevented the judge from . As a private law school, Stanford is not bound by the First Amendment, though California state law does apply some First Amendment protections to private universities. wrote 21 CFR Chapter I Subchapter H Medical Devices, https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-21/chapter-I/subchapter-H. Center for Devices and Radiological Health. According to their letter, Our disruption policy states that students are not allowed to prevent the effective carrying out of a public event whether by heckling or other forms of interruption.. [1] A device is defined by Section 201(h)(1) of the FFDCA as: An instrument, apparatus, implement, machine, contrivance, implant, in vitro reagent, or other similar or related article, including a component part, or accessory which is: In recognizing the increased role that software plays in healthcare and products relating to healthcare, the FDA decided to follow the International Medical Device Regulators Forum (IMDRF)s definition relating to software as medical devices (SaMD) and defines SaMD as software intended to be used for one or more medical purposes that perform these purposes without being part of a hardware medical device. Stanford DEI Dean Who Accosted Trump Judge Leaves Law School - MSN The New Kid on the Block: Prescription Video Games, Part II All Rights Reserved. Stanford Law students walk out on speaker discussing legality of DACA repeal, Students of color accuse Stanford Law School of being steeped in racism, Students list Apache attack helicopter as gender on engineering culture survey, angering scholars, Conservative magazine names best colleges and universities in America, Acquitted Yale student can sue rape accuser for defamation: court, Harvard ethics professor allegedly fabricated multiple behavioral science studies, Texas professor fired after teaching sex is determined by chromosomes: legal group, Powered by the Student Free Press Association. Shapiro has some unfortunate experience on this front. The Washington Free Beacon 's Aaron Sibarium appeared Sunday on Fox News and shared his blunt response to "hypocritical" Stanford Law School students who have demanded their names . [8] Akilis therapeutic computer game snares world-first approval, Evaluate.com (2020), https://www.evaluate.com/vantage/articles/news/snippets/akilis-therapeutic-computer-game-snares-world-first-approval; Akili Reports Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2022 Financial Results and Provides Business Update, (2023), https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20230307005504/en/Akili-Reports-Fourth-Quarter-and-Full-Year-2022-Financial-Results-and-Provides-Business-Update. Stanford Law School dean Jenny Martinez apologized to Duncan after the incident went viral, drawing yet another protest from students for what they viewed as a capitulation to an unreformed bigot . [3] Eunhye Choi, Eun-Ha Yoon & Min-Hyeon Park, Game-based digital therapeutics for children and adolescents: Their therapeutic effects on mental health problems, the sustainability of the therapeutic effects and the transfer of cognitive functions, 13 Frontiers in Psychiatry (2022), https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyt.2022.986687. [11] Shelley Moore [R-WV Sen. Capito, S.3791 117th Congress (2021-2022): Access to Prescription Digital Therapeutics Act of 2022, (2022), http://www.congress.gov/; Shelley Moore [R-WV Sen. Capito, S.5238 117th Congress (2021-2022): Medicaid and CHIP Access to Prescription Digital Therapeutics Act, (2022), http://www.congress.gov/. Duncan accepted the apology, and in particular was pleased with the reprimand of Steinbach, he told Whelan. Video and audio has gone viral of students interrupting, shouting and insulting the judge, who was appointed by former President Trump, over his conservative views. Stanford Law protesters demand to have names redacted from news - MSN (2019), https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/general-wellness-policy-low-risk-devices. Rosenberger, the Federalist Society's chapter president, said even Duncan's entrance into the room was a "dark moment," noting he'd gotten coffee with the judge before they returned to school, and "you could hear this din" from the building as they approached where he would be speaking. [7] Developed by professional video game developers, the game provides players with an immersive visual entertaining experience taking their space cadet into different galaxies to complete missions and tasks by saving alien creatures from extinction and providing them with rewards in the form of an in-game currency to upgrade their characters and spaceships. Arnold did not respond to a request for comment. It cannot do both. See the full episode here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Npri0P6UY-U Did you knowLOOPcast is on yo. Yet dozens of student protesters, some of whom had their faces painted and carried signs that read RESPECT TRANS RIGHTS, FEDSUCK and BE PRONOUN NOT PRO-BIGOT, ignored that policy when they shouted down not only the gay Federalist Society member tasked with introducing Duncan, but the judge himself. In Part I of this blog post I provided an overview of the first prescription video game, EndeavorRx, that has been cleared by the FDA for treating attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) symptoms in children between the ages of 8 and 12 years, expanding the market for digital therapeutics (DTx) to video games. The fliers parroted the argument, made by student activists, that the hecklers veto is a form of free speech. Manipur: India outrage after women paraded naked in violence-hit state Fox News' Joe Silverstein contributed to this report. Is this what the future holds for the legal profession? [6], Like most other video games, the difficulty of the game is adjusted according to each players progress, by measuring their performance through adaptive algorithms but for EndeavorRx the difficulty adjustment is specifically created in a manner to provide a player with a personalized treatment experience. Email this reporter: cdavis@insider.com. Why was there an illegal China-linked bio lab in Fresno? Circuit Court Judge Kyle Duncan. 53), WATCH: Joe Biden's Senior Moment of the Week (Vol. statements from at least three student groups rebuking Martinezs apology. In a conversation with students after the event, Steinbach claimed the hecklers hadnt violated any law school policies, according to two people who witnessed the conversation. Students at As a game-based DTx, EndeavorRx provides a non-drug option to improve ADHD symptoms in children in a manner which is fun and engaging. Nearly everyone in the room showed up to disrupt the proceeding, according to Duncan and two members of the Federalist Society, and many of the hundred or so students on hand were holding profane signs, including one that declared: Duncan cant find the clit,' the Beacon reported. July 20, 2023 . By utilizing a general video game function of adjusting the difficulty level according to a players progress, game-based DTx provides a more effective personalized treatment to players. Stanford Law School Ousts Diversity Dean Who Egged on Protest of Federal Judge Aaron Sibarium. March 14, 2023 04:51 PM S tudents at Stanford Law School staged a protest against Dean Jenny Martinez on Monday after she apologized for the disruption of an event featuring federal. Further, being a visual method of treatment instead of an informational-based treatment method, game-based DTx is more accessible to younger individuals and individuals who have limited literacy skills. VIDEO: Stanford Students, Admins Shout Down Federal Judge - Tampa "They gave us weird looks if we didnt wear black" and join the crowd, said Luke Schumacher, in Martinezs class who declined to participate in the protest. The majority of Martinezs classapproximately 50 students out of the 60 enrolledparticipated in the protest themselves, two students in the class said. Hundreds of Georgetown Law Center students sought his firing last year after he sent a tweet lamenting President Biden's stated desire to nominate a Black woman to the Supreme Court; while he meant it as a critique of identity politics in terms of restricting candidates by race and gender, Shapiro's terminology was construed as racially biased, and the firestorm began. [2] DTx, which consists of software programs that treat, manage or prevent a disorder or disease, which can perform its function without a specific hardware device, will therefore fall into the SaMD category regulated by the FDA. Analysts predict that EndeavorRxs sales in the US will peak at USD300 million, and Akili reported a 166% growth of their EndeavorRx sales from 2021 to 2022. Classifying it as a Class II prescription device indicates that from a regulatory perspective, the FDA recognizes the potential harm that game-based DTx can hold if not proven safe and effective. Their de novo classification request for their video game as a Class II device was, The de novo classification request described EndeavorRx as a digital therapeutic device for Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) which is a software intended to provide therapy for ADHD or any of its individual symptoms as an adjunct to clinician supervised treatment. Ugly Stanford Law protest of judge shows 'something has gone very wrong In response to the growing market of medical mobile applications and medical software programs which aim to promote a healthy lifestyle, the FDA released guidelines in 2019 to clarify the regulation of low-risk general wellness products.