why was brody killed off in homeland

I disliked him from the get-go and had no respect for him or what his brain-washed psyche stood for. READ. As far as Im concerned the Homeland that was is over without the Brody/Carrie dynamic. Really Normally in hangings the condemned is dropped so the sudden stop at the end breaks the next. I feel like the story with Brody is not finished. I would not be surprised if you saw Jessica or Dana one or two more times. TVLINE | Why did you decide not to show Jessica or Danas reaction to learning of Brodys death and that he died a hero? In the end, substance usually defeats process. Brody is dead. The rope appeared more under his chin than around his neck. Get him down! I had forgotten that waving my arms [was the signal] that I was choking! and your damn writers hope the ratings falls so drastically you turned the great show to semi boring show then to a terrible show very sad. . And indeed if Carrie had been successful in convincing Lockhart to put Brodys star up on the wall, it would have been an anonymous star. Below, the Emmy-winning actor says goodbye to Nicholas Brody, his popular Homeland starring character who was executed in a public square in Tehran during the shows last episode of the season Sunday night. I think this will be it for me with Homeland. From the writers pow, killing off characters is a way to add to the dramatic tension of course and it's essentially a plot device that gives main characters motivation and moves the story forward. This season was so boring until Brody came back not sure if I can watch it without him. Comments are monitored, so dont forkin' curse and dont bore us with how much your coworkers sister-in-law makes per hour. For me Season 3 was a major disappointment from start to finish, even more so because season 1 and 2 was so compelling. And what made it worse is that Carrie kept working for these people, they literally fed Brody to the wolves after he completed what they set him out to do, and she goes back to work with them, for themand they didnt even have the decency to clean his name for the langley bombing! ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: When did you learn your characters fate? Sinad OConnor on Mental Health and the Media, The Anniversary You Cant Refuse: 40 Things You Didnt Know About. Carrie takes over, and convinces Brody to become a triple agent for the CIA. Deal with it. Over the next few days, Brody gives a series of interviews on Iranian television denouncing the United States, leaving Saul no choice but to order his death. Carrie takes Brody to a motel where Dana is working as a maid but does not let him see her; she says that he must first atone for what he has done by taking part in the operation. In the third season, he is executed by Iranian authorities after completing a CIA operation against the Iranian Revolutionary Guard. Meaning of Radiohead's Kid A "Bear" Art: Inspired by Charles Burchfield? Who we consider the stars of shows die on a regular basis. Half of the writers should be woman for much better balance of the story. And theres the blind item. Game of Thrones Infographic: Why Did They Have to Die? The radical solution, apparently against Showtime's wishes, was amputation: Brody was killed off, publicly hanged from a crane in Tehran as punishment for killing the head of Iranian . Brody converted to Islam while in captivity. I didnt miss me at all. Look back at the show's most memorable goodbyes ahead of Sunday's season 5 premiere. In 2009, however, Issa was killed in a drone strike while attending school. In a plot masterminded by Nazir, Brody set himself up to be rescued by American forces. RELATED |HomelandSeason 3 Finale Recap: Who Died? Watched the Season 4 finale again. Her likability made the particularly brutal way she died not only shocking, but devastating. 2023 TIME USA, LLC. BBC News. [6] He tells his Saudi contact, Monsour Al-Zahrani (Ramsey Faragallah), to tell Nazir that he will not go through with their planned attack a suicide bombing at a State Department policy summit that he and Walden will be attending. I really was hoping for something a little more hearty. by Maitri Suhas. Hes not dead. Which they did. The only thing that could have been more correct about Homeland's season finale would have been calling it a series finale. But now we are sobbing over his demise on the series. I AM NOT WATCHING NEXT SEASON EITHER!! Unfortunately you cant always get what you want, so Saul isnt there working with them as part of the team, but I cant wait to see where the show goes. Destined to be cancelled. All rights reserved. Are there any shows left that have not aired their mid-season or season finales yet? In 2012, Brody won a special election for the Virginia congressional seat vacated by congressman Richard Johnson. The Showtime drama wraps its third season with Damian Lewis' character hanging in the balance after three years of close calls. How he died: Declared an enemy of the Iranian government in season 3, Brody was sentenced to a public execution by hanging. TVLINE | And Rupert Friend? Could be wrong but how much of the finale was also pushed along by Damian Lewis decision to put the character to bed and finally move on??? signed, everyone. THAT HE IS BEING SECRETLY HELPED BY SAL AGAIN! This site is protected by reCAPTCHA Enterprise and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Following his rescue and return home, Brody is hailed as a war hero and promoted to Gunnery Sergeant. Alone and confused in her room, Brody suddenly appears to comfort Carrie. In the UK we get Homeland later than the US. And the way Carrie was treated, disrespected, even shot, has been most disturbing to watch. I am done with the show even though its available to watch. [11] Meanwhile, Brody meets Roya Hammad (Zuleikha Robinson), a journalist who gives an assignment from Nazir instructing him to retrieve a list of potential attack targets from a safe in Estes' office. RELATED |HomelandExclusive: Two Original Castmembers Not Returning as Regulars in Season 4, All [the] evidence points to his death, undoubtedly, exec producerAlex Gansa tells TVLine,dismissing speculation that Brodys public hanging was somehow staged. I am also devistated that they killed Brody! Shortly thereafter, Brody watched an interview with Vice President William Walden (Jamey Sheridan), who falsely claimed that no children were killed in the drone strike. This is not real life but entertainment. [18] That night, after learning that Nazir has been killed, Brody leaves Jessica and reunites with Carrie. [16], Brody makes good on his pledge to help stop Nazir's attack. AND SO IS EVERYONE ELSE THAT I TALK TOTHEY LOVE BRODYHE WAS THE POINT OF THE SHOW. i really thought brody was the core of the show apart from carrie.both of them were really good characters and had really good chemistry and a good dynamic.i dont know how they are going to create another interesting story line for next season.i dont know if ill watch the show again cos i really like brody on my tv screen. There were 2 lead characters Carrie & Brody. Hes an ex-Brody. Walker, the Marine Two, returned to the United States with a mission from Nazir. Can you imagine their outrage if the next headline on TvLine right now was Damien Lewis to star in a new show? But I do find myself less interested. Updated December 17, 2013 at 11:41 PM EST, Homeland interview: Showrunner explains Brodys fate, season 4 plan. His character originally was supposed to die at the end of Season 1. Meanwhile, Berenson finds Brody's suicide tape in Beirut and gives it to Estes. I think they did a really good job with it. Hes super, super, super dead. That question was answered in episode 7 of Homeland Season 4, and in retrospect the answer to the riddle seems pretty obvious. Too many male writers on board. You must have seen it coming, but that didnt make it any easier. After carrying out the mission, Walker was killed by Brody, the Marine . He was also nominated for the Golden Globe Award for Best Actor Television Series Drama and Critics' Choice Television Award for Best Drama Actor. I was sobbing yes it was a tear jerker! "I can confirm that, yes, Damien Lewis was in Cape Town on the set. (If he does, the levels of shark-vaulting will be off the charts, and this show will be toast, for real.). What is the meaning of the Radiohead bear logo? Carrie tries to dissuade him, saying that he will die if he goes in alone; Brody replies that she will have to think of a way to get him out safely. Under pressure, Brody meets Hammad and says he wants out of the plot. The real world does have enough misery. But this stone-cold killing reminded us that the dubious American hero was loyal to, and only to, the al-Qaeda operative. Instead, the finale of Season 3 on Sunday cheated viewers of a classic thriller ending. Its less likely Ill jump right back into a TV show this year. Brody first came to the publics attention in 2003, when he and a fellow Marine were captured by Baathist forces while serving in the Iraq War. I agree! Another ending that leaves a question in my mind was the finally to breaking bad. I think the move of killing him was one they wrote themselves into. Carrie calls him in his cell to reassure him that she will save him, but he replies that he has accepted his fate and just wants it to be over. Brody soon grew to love the boy as his own son. I was within Brodys story. Was everyone on the same page this time around? [9], Six months after the State Department attack, Brody has been elected to the House of Representatives, representing Virginia's 7th congressional district. Why it was shocking: As the man who held Brody captive for eight years, Nazir was the bad guy on Homeland. [24], Brody escapes with Carrie to a safe house, where she tells him she is pregnant with his child. Thats what Ive been thinking too, that something happened behind the scenes and the storyline was changed. Perhaps this is a ruse put on by Jivadi. So the take away, he follows through on his plans regardless if its from a terrorist or the government. I just hoped we would honor all those things. Carrie Mathison (Claire Danes) has an offer to run the CIA office in Istanbul, her dream gig, and toward that end she's seriously considering giving up Brody's baby, which is about a month from. No Brody and No saul/Carrie relationship anymore? The blind item implied that the character was being written off of the show and THATs why he got another job. The death of Sergeant Nicholas Brody (played by Damien Lewis) on Showtime's hit TV series Homeland was certainly a bold plot move, but fans can't help but wonder if Brody is really dead. [1], As he settles back into civilian life, Brody struggles with posttraumatic stress disorder and has nightmares about his captivity in Damascus, all of which takes a toll on his family. My favorite part of Homeland is Carrie and Brody's relationship, so I am so upset they killed him. Move. The show really did change. As Brody prepares to detonate the vest, however, he finds that it does not work. And if so why didnt Carrie threaten to expose him had he not saved Brody. It would be nice if Carrie took Quinn and Virgil with her to Istanbul and Im happy Saul is returning. Surely there is so much latitude for Nicholas to be magically hanged but somehow saved. Hes really, really dead. I agree -what an awful ending .It was so sad and I wont watch it again /. Im sorry but I get enough of the real world in the REAL WORLD sometimes you want someone to magically make it through something like this on a show. Why it was shocking: The murders and their gory aftermath were shocking chiefly because of their brutality. Nicholas Brody, played by actor Damian Lewis, is a fictional character on the American television series Homeland on Showtime, created by Alex Gansa and Howard Gordon. Too early to tell if Ill be back for more next year!!!! By subscribing, I agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. So before we reunite with Carrie Mathison (Claire Danes) for Sundays season 5 premiere, take a look back at all of Homelands bombshell farewells that left us astonished. [20], In the aftermath of the Langley bombing, Brody becomes one of the world's most wanted fugitives. The Eliza Dushku-starring 2003 horror film was followed by six other movies, with two more planned. Who needs it! You are totally right!!! Were going to shoot that in Morocco in January. And now without Brody I can see no way back, as Lockhart and Dar Adal are about as compelling to watch as a slice of moldy bread. Thats really what I was concentrating on, trying to do that in a credible way while having the life choked out of me. [10] Walden approaches Brody and offers to tap him as his running mate during his planned presidential campaign. So "Homeland" ended with a deus ex loose-wire and a major character getting a memory wipe? REALLY? Notify me of follow-up comments by email. The hero of "Homeland" did not cheat death. He wasnt dropped to break his neck and they didnt show a nasty rotting corpse hung up on that Christmas noose four months later. She needs the job: 1. she is pregnant and 2. her sister cant continue stealing medicines for her forever she has a few kids of her own and needs her job and her own health insurance. I knew he had become a popular character so I wanted him served well. However, the interrogation is stopped by Carrie's superior, Counterterrorism Center director David Estes (David Harewood). Brody later abandoned this plan at the urging of his daughter. Are you open to future appearances that involve dream sequences or flashbacks? ET on Showtime. He told Carrie he didnt want her to be there. Lewis reveals what it was like to shoot his agonizing last scene, what he thinks Brody was thinking in those final moments and his feelings about the shows future without him. Shakespeare & Hathaway: Private Investigators, Sinad OConnors Cause of Death: New Details Emerge, Revisiting Sinad OConnors Infamous Pope Protest on, Mitch McConnell Suddenly Freezes During Press Conference, Sparking Health Concerns Watch, Sinad OConnor, Grammy Winner and Nothing Compares 2 U Singer, Dead at 56, Box Office: 'Barbie' Opens to Record-Setting $155 Million, 'Oppenheimer' Shatters Expectations With $80 Million Debut, Box Office Stunner: 'Barbie' Opens to Staggering $162M, 'Oppenheimer' Snags $82.4M, Melania Trumps Latest Controversial Venture May Find Her in Hot Water With NASA, Doja Cat Tells Fans She Doesn't Love Them, Disdains "Kittenz" Fan Club Nickname, Viola Davis Steps Back From G20 Despite Pics SAG-AFTRA Waiver: Not Appropriate For This Production To Move Forward During Strike, Brad Pitt Hits Brakes On F1 Film In Support OfStrike, Sharon Stone Says Paul Verhoeven Played Every Other Basic Instinct Screen Test Against Hers None Measured Up, UFC 291: How to Watch Dustin Poirier vs. Justin Gaethje Online, Bowflexs SelectTech Adjustable Dumbbells Are On Sale for Over 20% Off. Brodie could be working again this time for the Iranians, or perhaps he will be the new Osama bin laden. Were you happy with how Brodys story ended? I always wanted him to get caught in his terrorist efforts as Im sure most patriotic viewers did as well. Language links are at the top of the page across from the title. Either way RIP Brody.he was a huge part of why I loved the show. REALLY?! An old-fashioned beheading would leave no doubt at all. It was emotional to watch. We really dont know for sure if her baby is Brodys ; if you remember she had sex with that red- haired substitute guy ! After it is revealed that Walker is alive and was also turned, Brody angrily rejects Carrie and goes back to his family. Looking forward to season 4. HE NEEDS TO FIX THIS SHOW OR ELSE THE MAJORITY OF THE FANS WILL BE DISAPPOINTED. There was pushback this season. There was pushback at the end of the first season. Between the first and second season, he is elected to Congress, but at the end of the second season he is framed for committing a terrorist bombing. It's always shocking when a TV show kills off a main character. He was hanging and choking. Tired of the old story line! Actor Damien Lewis was seen hanging around on Homeland's South African set during the filming of season four, seeming to many like a sure-fire indication that his character would in fact return on the fourth season of the Showtime series. Rose, just because you post this same opinion on this here over and over doesnt make it right. dude, hes DEAD. And people are cool with this? COMING UP: 7 AM ET - Wake Up America 9 AM ET -. Meaning of Radiohead OK Computer Song "True Love Waits", W.A.S.T.E. Brody assisted Nazir in assassinating Walden, only to be framed by al-Qaeda for the bombing at CIA headquarters that killed 200 people, among them the Secretary of Defense and the Secretary of Homeland Security. I dont care if they end the whole show but Brody deserves some kind of happy ending after all they put him through.I wont watch again either. You can only manipulate the viewers emotions so much. Bye Bye. I just cant find myself caring for Saul and his new job or how Carrie will fare with a baby, her job and her illness. The Star was sad, but it was a beautifully tragic goodbye to a beautifully tragic character. It was a very serendipitous piece of scheduling, because usually the schedule is all over the place. Though Brody may be dead, it seems very probable that he could make a repeat appearance on Homeland in the future in this phantom state. Only the intervention of Showtime (CBS) executives changed that plan. From here both the CIA and al-Qaeda used Brody as an agent to further their goals, with the congressman caught in the middle. All Rights Reserved. Good comment no one else said it. You saw the noose put around his neck. While thinking a CIA extraction team was on the way, Javadi's men arrive and take Brody into custody, part of a deal the CIA made with Javadi to help him advance to greater power within the Iranian government. Berenson and Carrie offer Brody a chance to redeem himself by seeking political asylum in Iran and assassinating the head of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, General Danesh Akbari (Houshang Touzie), so that CIA asset Majid Javadi (Shaun Toub) can take his place. This week on Showtime's Homeland, Carrie tried to motivate Brody to get the horse off his back, while Saul got an illuminating eyeful of his wife's gentleman "friend.". I dont think I want to watch the show anymore because the way they left off was that OUR COUNTRY would leave one of its own, that has sacrificed his whole life for OUR Government out in the cold after achieving an impossible mission. Carrie summons him to consult about the interrogation of Afsal Hamid, her torturer during captivity. Have not watched this #Homeland in advance, but my prediction is Brody is saved by a Showtime executive who stops a bullet with his hand. For his portrayal of Nicholas Brody in the premiere season of Homeland, Damian Lewis received the Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series. It's funny because it's true. And it is later discovered that Afsal killed himself in his cell using a razor blade. Just let it be done with. Despite his initial reluctance, Brody procures the list. I thought it was some king of Seal breath storage thing and he kept talking about not being able to die like a cockroach. if the USA had a spy in Iran to kill someone to get a puppet official/president into power and had to sacrifice 1 American citizen to do it. He was a real hero and it was stupid to let him die. Brody initially shuns the spotlight, physically assaulting a reporter who enters his backyard. Dead. Will you continue to watch the show as a fan? Ultimately, it came down to the fact that if you couldnt tell the Brody family this piece of information, their responses would be no different than the responses that weve seen from them already. I think Brody was the blind item, his new project just may have fell through or maybe something happened behind the scenes and he was recast. The bomb that exploded at the memorial service * of Vice-President Bill Walden 40 minutes into "The Choice" rebooted the series through creative destruction. HE UNDER HIDING AND STAGING A PLAN TO TAKE DOWN THE HEAD OF THE CIA. genre Thriller SPOILER ALERT! Why I think Brody is behind the attack. Though it seems that he is an all-American hero, CIA counterterrorism operative. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); They left enough wiggle room to bring him back if the numbers warrant it. TVLINE | Its no secret that you considered killing off Brody sooner than Season 3, but Showtime pushed back. Legomenon: What is the Meaning? So Dana and Jessica would never be allowed to be privy to that. TVLINE | It's no secret that you considered killing off Brody sooner than Season 3, but Showtime pushed back. Born in the Mojave Desert, when his father was stationed at the MCAGCC, Gunnery Sergeant Nicholas Brody was a United States Marine Corps Force Reconnaissance Scout Sniper deployed during the Iraq War. Sex and the City turns 25: A conversation with Skipper, Carrie's nice-guy pal from season 1. I wanted him to go out with a bang. Roya tells him to help an al-Qaeda bomb maker get to a safe house, but Brody ends up killing the man when he tries to escape. There is still hate towards the VP and CIA in Brody. Tired of the old story line! Thank goodness we are moving on finally. Even so, Carrie sets up a slipshod intelligence operation and bugs Brody's house. On. We felt it would be a retread, and not as compelling as chronicling Carries reaction to his death. How he died: The Director of the CIAs Counterterrorism Center (David Harewood) was killed when a car bomb goes off outside of the agencys headquarters in Langley, Virginia during a memorial service for Vice President Walden in the season 2 finale. [13] During the ensuing interrogation, new team leader Peter Quinn (Rupert Friend) stabs Brody in the hand. Homelandfans are still holding out for a miracle. One burning question down, another 10 to go. Ethnic violence has plunged the small Indian state of Manipur into what many have dubbed a state of civil war as the two largest groups, the majority Meitei and minority Kuki, battle .

Sponsored link

How Much Do Hvac Installers Make, Articles W

Sponsored link
Sponsored link